Once Upon a Farm's food can contain trace heavy metals, like any food made from fruits, vegetables and grains, but the brand publishes lot-level test results across its whole range and earned a top transparency score from Consumer Reports and Unleaded Kids. We found no independent lab test of its baby pouches; the one independent test we found, of a refrigerated oat bar in 2024, reported total arsenic at or above 10 ppb.
Below is what Once Upon a Farm publishes, what outside groups have found, and the shelf-stable picks we recommend on Amazon. For the full ranked list, see our guide to baby food brands without heavy metals.
What Once Upon a Farm publishes
Once Upon a Farm says it was "the first kids' brand to deliver test result transparency across our entire product portfolio," including snacks for older children. Its standards page links to a results portal, and its FAQ says that if a pouch has no QR code, you can "use the UPC to look up other lot test results."
The same page sets out the benchmarks the company says it follows: FDA's lead action levels, European Union limits, and Clean Label Project standards. It says that "when specific guidelines are absent, we set our own standards."
If you have a pouch in hand, our guide to finding your baby food's heavy metal test results explains how to read a lot result once you find it.
Certifications
Once Upon a Farm says it holds the Clean Label Project Purity Award and the Clean Label Project Pesticide-Free Certification.
The Purity Award is a relative benchmark, not a pass mark. Clean Label Project compares a product's test results with others in its category, and a product qualifies if its results are in the top 33 percent. It tells you the product tested better than most in its category when tested. It does not mean the metals are absent.
What independent groups have found
Transparency. In August 2025, Consumer Reports and Unleaded Kids reviewed 39 baby food brands on how easily parents can find heavy metal results. Their release named Earth's Best, Once Upon a Farm and Plum Organics as the top scorers.
Lab testing of baby food. Consumer Reports' 2026 tests of 48 baby foods covered 11 brands, and Once Upon a Farm was not one of them. It was also not among the seven companies in the February 2021 House subcommittee investigation of baby food metals.
One snack test. Lead Safe Mama, an independent advocate on childhood lead poisoning, published a September 2024 lab report on a Once Upon a Farm refrigerated strawberry oat bar. It reported total arsenic at or above 10 ppb, with lead, cadmium and mercury each below the lab's 10 ppb reporting threshold. The report did not separate inorganic arsenic, which Consumer Reports calls the most harmful form, from organic arsenic, and it covers one sample of a kids' bar, not a baby pouch.
What it means for a buyer
Once Upon a Farm is one of the more open brands about testing, and the evidence we found does not single it out for high metal levels. The gap is independent lab data on its baby pouches: so far the published numbers are the company's own. If you buy it, look up the lot and compare the lead figure with FDA's 10 ppb level for fruit and vegetable purees.
The practical catch is format. Once Upon a Farm pouches are refrigerated. On Amazon we found them only through Whole Foods Market grocery listings, so they are not in our Amazon picks.
Shelf-stable alternatives on Amazon
These brands also publish finished-product results and were in the same top transparency group:
- Best pouch for reading the numbers yourself: Plum Organics Stage 2 Apple & Carrot. Plum posts every batch in ppb in a public table, and the twelve batches listed when we checked ran from under 1 to 6 ppb lead.
- Best veggie-first pouch: Cerebelly Carrot Pumpkin. Cerebelly publishes results for every lot in market and says it holds the Purity Award.
- Best overall cereal: Earth's Best Organic Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal, rated 5 out of 5 for inorganic arsenic, cadmium and lead in CR's 2026 tests.
- Best multigrain cereal: Earth's Best Organic Multi-Grain Cereal, barley, oats and spelt with no rice, also 5 out of 5 on all three.
- Best if your store stocks Gerber: Gerber Organic Oatmeal Cereal, 5 out of 5 on all three, with batch results on Gerber.com.
- Best for introducing peanut: Mission MightyMe Organic Peanut Butter Puffs, sorghum based, with every finished product tested for heavy metals.
- Best toddler snack (ages 2+): Earth's Best Organic Veggie Puffs, corn based and 5 out of 5 on all three.
Wondering about another big brand? We cover whether Gerber has heavy metals and arsenic in rice cereal. More vetted picks are on our baby recommendations page.


