Back to JournalProduct Reviews

Baby Food Brands Without Heavy Metals: 8 Tested Picks That Publish Results

November 20, 20269 min read

No baby food brand is free of heavy metals. Lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury occur naturally in soil and water, so trace amounts turn up in fruits, vegetables and grains, organic or not. What you can choose is a brand that tests its finished food, publishes the numbers, and has tested low in independent lab work.

Our top pick is Earth's Best Organic Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal. Consumer Reports rated it 5 out of 5 for inorganic arsenic, cadmium and lead in its 2026 tests, and Earth's Best posts heavy metal results by product on its website.

Already holding a jar and want its numbers? Our guide to finding your baby food's heavy metal test results walks through the QR code and website lookup.

The short list

  1. Best overall: Earth's Best Organic Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal
  2. Best multigrain cereal: Earth's Best Organic Multi-Grain Cereal
  3. Best if your store stocks Gerber: Gerber Organic Oatmeal Cereal
  4. Best pouch for reading the numbers yourself: Plum Organics Stage 2 Apple & Carrot
  5. Best veggie-first pouch: Cerebelly Carrot Pumpkin
  6. Best for introducing peanut: Mission MightyMe Organic Peanut Butter Puffs
  7. Best puff for crawlers: Gerber Strawberry Apple Puffs
  8. Best toddler snack (ages 2+): Earth's Best Organic Veggie Puffs

Why no baby food is metal-free

The American Academy of Pediatrics puts it simply: "Metals are found naturally in the Earth's crust." Plants pull them from soil and water as they grow, and some crops take up more than others. The AAP says rice "tends to absorb more arsenic from groundwater than other crops."

The AAP also says the metals in baby food "likely are a relatively small part of a child's overall toxic metal exposure risk," while adding that "exposure from all sources should be minimized." On exposure itself, it says: "It's been linked to problems with learning, cognition and behavior."

Independent testing shows how common trace metals are. Consumer Reports tested 48 store-bought baby foods from 11 brands in 2026. It detected inorganic arsenic in 37, cadmium in 38 and lead in 41. In 96 percent of products, though, every metal was below CR's level of concern. In 2018, CR had found concerning levels in about two-thirds of the 50 products it tested. CR also found no consistent difference between organic and conventional products.

What the rules require

FDA's limits

In January 2025 FDA finalized guidance on lead in packaged food for children under two. The action levels are:

  • 10 ppb for fruits, vegetables (except single-ingredient root vegetables), mixtures, yogurts, custards and puddings, and single-ingredient meats
  • 20 ppb for single-ingredient root vegetables and dry infant cereals

FDA says the guidance does not cover "infant formula, beverages, or snack foods like puffs and teething biscuits." Like all FDA guidance, it is not legally binding, though FDA says it may regard food above these levels as adulterated.

For arsenic, FDA set 100 ppb inorganic arsenic as the action level for infant rice cereal in August 2020, and it has an arsenic action level for apple juice. FDA has no action level for cadmium or mercury in baby food.

California AB 899 and the states that followed

California's AB 899, signed in October 2023, requires baby food makers selling in the state to test a representative sample of each product at least monthly for arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury. Since 2025, results must be public on the company's website for the product's shelf life plus one month. A QR code on the label is required once FDA sets an action level for the metal in question. Infant formula is excluded.

Maryland and Virginia have similar laws; Virginia's took effect January 1, 2026. Illinois passed its own in 2025. Because large brands sell nationally, many now post results for every product, not just the ones shipped to California.

The 2021 congressional report

In February 2021 a House Oversight subcommittee published internal test data from four baby food companies: Nurture (HappyBABY), Beech-Nut, Hain Celestial (Earth's Best Organic) and Gerber. Three others, Campbell (Plum Organics), Walmart (Parent's Choice) and Sprout Organic Foods, refused to cooperate.

The report found arsenic, lead and cadmium in baby foods or ingredients from all four responding companies. It also found that "only Nurture routinely tested its finished product for lead," while Hain, Beech-Nut and Gerber tested ingredients only. A September 2021 follow-up added findings on Plum, Walmart and Sprout.

Several brands on our list were named in those reports. We kept them because they now publish results for finished products, the practice the report faulted them for skipping, and because later independent tests show lower levels. Each pick below notes its brand's history.

How we chose

Every pick had to clear all of these:

  1. Published results for finished product. The brand posts lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury results online by product, lot or batch.
  2. Easy access. The brand was in the top group of the August 2025 review by Consumer Reports and Unleaded Kids, which rated 39 brands on how easily parents can find results. Sixteen made that group.
  3. Independent data where it exists. Products rated 5 out of 5 for lead, cadmium and inorganic arsenic in CR's 2026 tests, with no serving limit, rank higher.
  4. Rice-free where possible, following the AAP's advice to rotate grains.
  5. Sold on Amazon in a normal multi-pack.

We note the Clean Label Project Purity Award where a brand holds it. It is a relative award: a product qualifies when its test results rank in the top 33 percent of its category. It is not a fixed limit.

The picks

1. Earth's Best Organic Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal: best overall

Earth's Best Organic Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal is oat flour, an enzyme, iron and vitamin E. CR's 2026 tests rated it 5 out of 5 for inorganic arsenic, cadmium and lead, with no serving limit. Earth's Best says it tests all baby food for the four metals and sends finished products to a third-party lab.

Watch for: the label lists wheat. Hain, its maker, was one of the four companies in the 2021 report.

2. Earth's Best Organic Multi-Grain Cereal: best multigrain cereal

Earth's Best Organic Multi-Grain Cereal combines barley, oats and spelt, with no rice. The AAP says multigrain infant cereals "can be a good choice." CR rated it 5 out of 5 for all three metals it scores.

Watch for: barley and spelt contain gluten.

3. Gerber Organic Oatmeal Cereal: best if your store stocks Gerber

Gerber Organic Oatmeal Cereal also earned 5 out of 5 for all three metals in CR's tests, with no serving limit. Gerber says results for everything made after January 1, 2025 are on Gerber.com by batch, and the QR code on the box links there.

Watch for: buy the organic version. Gerber's conventional oatmeal rated 3 out of 5 for inorganic arsenic in the same tests. Our Gerber heavy metals breakdown covers the rest of the range.

4. Plum Organics Stage 2 Apple & Carrot: best pouch for reading the numbers yourself

Plum posts every batch in a public table, in ppb, sorted by best-before date. No lot code needed. The twelve batches of Plum Organics Stage 2 Apple & Carrot listed when we checked ran from under 1 to 6 ppb lead, all under FDA's 10 ppb level.

Watch for: CR rated it 3 out of 5 for lead and suggested no more than two servings a day. The September 2021 subcommittee report said Plum's finished products then contained up to 225 ppb inorganic arsenic.

5. Cerebelly Carrot Pumpkin: best veggie-first pouch

Cerebelly publishes lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury for every lot in market, with test dates, plus a lot-code lookup. Cerebelly Carrot Pumpkin leads with vegetables and has no added sugar. Cerebelly says it holds the Clean Label Project Purity Award.

Watch for: results are in micrograms per pouch against California Prop 65 levels, not ppb. CR tested a different Cerebelly pouch and found no metals above its level of concern, but did detect the phthalate DEHP and microplastics.

6. Mission MightyMe Organic Peanut Butter Puffs: best for introducing peanut

Mission MightyMe Organic Peanut Butter Puffs are more than half peanut, and the brand has moved them from rice flour to sorghum flour. MightyMe says it tests every finished product for heavy metals and that every product holds the Purity Award.

Watch for: not in CR's 2026 tests. Ask your pediatrician before introducing peanut.

7. Gerber Strawberry Apple Puffs: best puff for crawlers

CR found that snacks such as puffs, rusks and bars generally carried more metals than purees, often because they are rice based. Gerber Strawberry Apple Puffs were an exception, rated 5 out of 5 for all three metals with no serving limit. The current ingredient list starts with sorghum flour.

Watch for: added cane sugar, and older canisters may still list rice flour.

8. Earth's Best Organic Veggie Puffs: best toddler snack (ages 2+)

Earth's Best Organic Veggie Puffs are corn based and rated 5 out of 5 for all three metals in CR's tests. They carry USDA Organic, gluten-free and Non-GMO Project marks.

Watch for: the bag says ages 2 and up.

Comparison table

ProductResults publishedIndependent lab data (CR 2026)CertificationFormat
Earth's Best Organic Oatmeal CerealBy product, earthsbest.com5/5 lead, cadmium, inorganic arsenicUSDA Organic, CLP Purity Award8 oz box, 12-pack
Earth's Best Organic Multi-Grain CerealBy product, earthsbest.com5/5 all threeUSDA Organic, CLP Purity Award8 oz box, 12-pack
Gerber Organic Oatmeal CerealBy batch, Gerber.com and QR5/5 all threeUSDA Organic, Non-GMO Project8 oz, 6-pack
Plum Organics Apple & CarrotEvery batch in ppb, public table3/5 lead, 5/5 othersUSDA Organic4 oz pouch, 12-pack
Cerebelly Carrot PumpkinEvery active lot, cerebelly.comOther flavor tested: no metals above concernUSDA Organic, CLP Purity Award (brand)4 oz pouch, 6-pack
Mission MightyMe Peanut PuffsRated easy to access by CR and Unleaded KidsNot testedUSDA Organic, CLP Purity Award (brand)1.5 oz bag, 5-pack
Gerber Strawberry Apple PuffsBy batch, Gerber.com and QR5/5 all threeNone1.48 oz, 6-pack
Earth's Best Organic Veggie PuffsBy product, earthsbest.com5/5 all threeUSDA Organic, Gluten-Free, Non-GMO Project1.55 oz bag, 4-pack

What did not make it

Gerber Rice Cereal. CR found it averaged 63 ppb inorganic arsenic. That is under FDA's 100 ppb action level, but over CR's level of concern at one serving a day, so CR suggests a half serving at most. Every oat and multigrain cereal CR tested rated better. Our rice cereal and arsenic guide has the details.

Happy Baby Organics. No Happy Baby product exceeded CR's level of concern for heavy metals in 2026, but Consumer Reports and Unleaded Kids placed it in the middle group because finding results requires extra details such as a lot number. CR's 2023 tests found its Superfood Puffs had the highest average arsenic and lead of the products tested that year; Happy Baby has since discontinued them.

Once Upon a Farm. It earned a top transparency score and holds the Purity Award, but its pouches are refrigerated, and on Amazon we found them only through Whole Foods Market listings. See our Once Upon a Farm heavy metals answer.

FAQ

Is any baby food free of heavy metals?

No. Metals occur naturally in soil and water, and CR detected lead in 41 of the 48 baby foods it tested in 2026. The realistic goal is lower levels and published results.

Is organic baby food lower in heavy metals?

Not reliably. CR's 2026 tests found no noticeable or consistent difference between organic and conventional baby foods. CR says organic may reduce exposure to synthetic pesticides, but both kinds take up metals from soil and water.

What does "ND" mean on a results page?

"Not detected" means below the lab's detection limit, not zero. Consumer Reports and Unleaded Kids note that California's law requires testing only down to 6 ppb, so "ND" can cover anything under that.

Is homemade baby food lower in heavy metals?

Not necessarily. Consumer Reports says homemade baby food "may not be lower in toxic elements," and that both homemade and store-bought food can contain heavy metals. The AAP's advice on variety applies to both.

More answers

The takeaway

Skip the search for a metal-free label; none exists. Pick brands that publish finished-product results, rotate grains away from rice, and favor products with good independent data. More vetted picks are on our baby recommendations page.