Back to JournalHow-To Guides

Can You Mix Creatine With Protein Powder? What to Mix Creatine With

September 19, 20264 min read

Yes. Creatine and protein powder mix fine in the same shake, and one controlled study found that taking each dose with about 50 grams of protein plus 47 grams of carbohydrate increased how much creatine the body retained, far more than a typical shake. Beyond protein shakes, creatine works in water, milk, coffee or juice; just drink acidic mixes like juice soon after mixing.

For the creatine itself, start with our tested creatine picks. Below is what the research says about mixing, and a practical guide to each drink.

What the research says about creatine and protein

The best-known study here is Steenge, Simpson and Greenhaff, 2000, in the Journal of Applied Physiology. Twelve men took four 5 gram doses of creatine in a day on four separate occasions, each time with a different add-on:

Taken with each 5 g creatine doseEffect on creatine retention
About 50 g protein plus 47 g carbohydrateAbout 25% higher than the placebo condition
96 g carbohydrateAbout 25% higher than the placebo condition

The placebo condition paired creatine with only 5 grams of carbohydrate, and another group took it with 50 grams. The authors concluded that creatine with about 50 grams of protein and carbohydrate was as effective at increasing creatine retention as creatine with almost 100 grams of carbohydrate. An earlier study by Green and colleagues, 1996 found the same direction of effect with carbohydrate alone, and a 2022 review in Nutrients states that co-ingesting creatine with carbohydrate "promotes more consistent and greater creatine retention."

Two honest caveats. These studies used loading-sized doses (20 grams a day), not the 3 to 5 grams most people take. And Steenge's group found the insulin effect on creatine uptake faded within the first 24 hours of supplementing. So a protein shake is a sensible place for creatine, not a requirement. Taken daily in plain water, creatine still fills your muscle stores over about three to four weeks, per the ISSN position stand.

What to mix creatine with

Protein shake

The most convenient option if you already drink one. Unflavored creatine adds no taste. Two protein powders on our list pair well:

  • Klean Athlete Klean Isolate: unflavored whey isolate that is NSF Certified for Sport, a match for an NSF-certified creatine if you are drug tested.
  • Legion Whey+: grass-fed whey isolate sweetened with stevia, if you want flavor and already use Legion's creatine.

Water

Fine, with one catch: creatine does not dissolve easily in cold water. The 2022 Nutrients review reports solubility of 14 grams per liter at 20 °C. By that figure, fully dissolving a 5 gram dose at room temperature takes roughly 360 mL, about 12 ounces. Less water than that leaves some grit at the bottom, which is still creatine, so swirl and finish it.

Warm water, tea or coffee

Heat helps. The same review reports solubility of 34 grams per liter at 50 °C, and that solubility "increases linearly with increasing temperature." Coffee is a popular choice; the caffeine question is covered in creatine with coffee.

Milk

Milk adds some protein and carbohydrate too, though a glass is far below the amounts in the retention study. Unflavored powder is barely noticeable in it.

Juice

Juice adds carbohydrate, which fits the retention research. The trade-off is that creatine in solution converts to creatinine "at a faster rate as pH decreases and temperature increases," according to the 2022 review. Juice is acidic, so mix it and drink it rather than letting it sit.

The one rule: mix it, then drink it

As a dry powder, creatine monohydrate is very stable; the 2022 review found no sign of degradation over years of storage. Dissolved creatine is less stable. The same review reports it is relatively stable for about three days at neutral pH, but breaks down faster in acidic drinks, so a cold shake made the night before is fine while creatine juice carried around all day is not ideal. If you want a no-mixing option, Legion Creatine Gummies are 1 gram each, five to a serving, and skip the shaker altogether.

You also do not need to time the shake around a workout for creatine's sake. What fills your stores is daily intake. See when to take creatine for the timing research.

Which creatine mixes best

More vetted supplements are on our supplements recommendations page, and our guide on how to take creatine covers dose and loading.

The bottom line

Put creatine in your protein shake if that is the drink you never skip. The research suggests protein and carbohydrate may help retention, especially during loading, but the bigger factor is taking 3 to 5 grams every day. Use warm liquid or at least 12 ounces of cold water for a smooth mix, and drink it right away.