We tested dozens of clean mascaras for length, volume, and staying power. These are the ones that actually deliver.
Finding a clean mascara that performs as well as conventional formulas used to feel impossible. They were clumpy, flaky, or disappeared by lunchtime. But clean beauty brands have finally cracked the code, creating mascaras that rival—and sometimes surpass—their traditional counterparts.
We tested 30+ clean mascaras over 8 hours of wear to find the best performers. Here are our top 10 picks.
We look for mascaras free from:
Price: $24 • Best For: Length & Definition
Why we love it: This mascara delivers serious length without clumping or flaking, even after 12+ hours. The innovative tapered brush separates and coats every lash. Vegan, cruelty-free, and ophthalmologist-tested for sensitive eyes.
The catch: Takes 30 seconds to dry completely—don't blink too soon!
$68 • Ultra-luxe refillable formula with jojoba oil and beeswax. Dramatic length without looking fake. Worth the splurge for sustainable luxury.
$28 • Buildable, volumizing formula with shea butter and arginine. Dual-sided brush for length and volume. Perfect for dramatic looks.
$20 • Ophthalmologist-tested, contact lens safe, and formulated specifically for sensitive eyes. Gentle yet effective with buildable color.
$28 • Organic formula with plant waxes for a "your lashes but better" look. Perfect for everyday wear and minimal makeup days.
$13.99 • Best drugstore option with impressive length and no flaking
$29 • Volumizing and lengthening in one with plant-based ingredients
$19 • Vegan formula with bamboo stem cells for conditioning lashes
$20 • Natural, nourishing formula great for short or sparse lashes
$12 • Budget-friendly vegan option that punches above its weight class
Clean mascara has come a long way. You no longer have to choose between performance and ingredient safety. Our top pick, Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions, delivers everything you want in a mascara—dramatic length, no flaking, and a clean ingredient list.
For those on a budget, Honest Beauty and Pacifica offer impressive results at drugstore prices. And if you're willing to splurge, Kjaer Weis delivers luxury performance in a gorgeous refillable package.